Transforming Problems and Tonglen |
|
| Tonglen |
|
| A student practicing tonglen wrote to
Rinpoche saying she didn’t understand really what
it meant to take on others' suffering. |
Dear Lorraine,
First, you have to know the benefits of the bodhicitta practice;
you have to have a big goal in mind. The purpose of life is
to free all sentient beings from all sufferings and to cause
them to have happiness, especially to bring them to enlightenment,
to free them from all defilements and sufferings.
The next thing, in order to perfectly do that, is that you
need the path to enlightenment. The door to enlightenment
is bodhicitta. Bodhicitta is the most important thing in life,
not only for your own benefit but in order to eliminate all
the defilements of countless other sentient beings, for everyone.
You need to know what bodhicitta is: it is renouncing oneself
and cherishing other sentient beings. You need to understand
this to be able to enjoy and accept the practice (tonglen).
That depends on how much you see self-cherishing as the enemy.
The more you see it as the enemy, the more you are able to
do tonglen practice sincerely.
You are not only taking the suffering of others, you are
taking all the undesirable things onto the ego and destroying
the ego. The ego is the enemy of bodhicitta. If there is ego,
there is no space in the mind for bodhicitta. Bodhicitta is
the wish-fulfilling, holy thought that brings all happiness
for oneself and for every sentient being.
The more you understand this, the more you will enjoy taking
the suffering of others and giving them all your happiness
and merit. How this benefits other sentient beings is because
the more you renounce the ego, the more you are able to practice
bodhicitta. It makes it possible to enter the Mahayana path
that eliminates both defilements, gross and subtle, and to
attain omniscience, so you are able to become enlightened
and do perfect works for sentient beings. You collect vast
amounts of merit each time you take others' sufferings or
give others your happiness. For example, each time you visualize
giving your body to others, you collect so much merit. Each
time you give your possessions, happiness, and merits to others,
you collect vast amounts of merit. Giving all of these are
the cause for achieving ultimate happiness. Each time we take
others' sufferings, we purify many eons of negative karma,
so we are able to achieve enlightenment soon, even in this
life.
The actual benefit of taking others' suffering, the long
term, ultimate benefit, is that you become enlightened for
the benefit of all sentient beings. This benefit is enormous,
like the vast sky, and what you can offer to each sentient
being is like the limitless sky.
This is the main benefit of this practice. Then, it becomes
more powerful purification than doing a three-month Vajrasattva
retreat, with comforts and ego. You are doing the Vajrasattva
retreat so you will not be born in the lower realms. This
is not a very powerful purification or sacrifice for others.
Sincerely taking others' suffering and its causes with strong
compassion, just once, purifies more than doing a one-year
Vajrasattva retreat.
With much love and prayer...
| Tonglen Practice |
|
| Rinpoche made the following comments
on tonglen practice. |
One time I was in England and we were driving to an office
for a meeting with the Maitreya Project designer, engineer,
architect, and environmental advisor, when these people were
going to present their ideas. We were stopped at a red light.
There was a middle-aged, well-dressed man, quite short,
crossing the road. He had such an awful body, with long, large
fleshy protrusions pointing out, covering his hands and face.
It was the first time I saw such a face and body. I pointed
him out to my companions. This one fortunate time I remembered
to practice tonglen. When you see such a suffering
being, practice tonglen. I pointed him out to one
of my companions and said "Quickly, quickly, practice
tonglen." I found that meditation quite effective.
You can take the suffering on yourself and give it all to
your ego, to destroy the ego, the self-cherishing thought.
One of my companions asked whether by doing this practice
it made the man's sickness meaningful, that it would get better.
I said it would be extremely beneficial to achieve enlightenment
to be able to benefit all beings. One can pray and dedicate
the merits from that practice for that person to be quickly
liberated from samsara. That means to stop all sicknesses,
however many hundreds of sicknesses there are, all sufferings,
and all the problems of life. So, this way of praying covers
everything. This meditation develops bodhicitta, enables oneself
to collect extensive merit, purify negative karma, and achieve
enlightenment more quickly. After that, you're able to perform
perfect work, not only for that person but for all sentient
beings, and are able to free them from the ocean of samsaric
suffering and bring them to enlightenment.
| Love and Compassion |
|
| Rinpoche offered this advice concerning
the practices of love and compassion. |
Although we have different definitions for love and compassion,
and during tonglen practice love and compassion are
practiced at different times, actually, they are not separate.
Just as smoke is a sign of fire, and with fire there is
smoke, so, too, where love is present, so is compassion. In
practice they come together.
When you are wishing to take on the suffering of others
sincerely, then you are also wishing for their happiness.
And when you are wishing sincerely for others’ happiness,
then you are also wishing to remove their suffering.
Although the thought of love and compassion does not arise
simultaneously, in practice they appear together.
| When Problems Interfere
with Practice |
|
| A young Italian student had been experiencing
various problems. Even though she was practicing, it seemed
that things kept getting worse. Then she became depressed,
and was unable to practice any longer. |
My very dear Laura,
Thank you very much for your kind letter.
All that you are experiencing is due to past karma. It is
still very good to continue to practice Lion-Face Dakini.
Also, if you can recite the White
Umbrella prayer. You should also perform Medicine Buddha
puja three times – you can practice it with other people.
It would also be very good if you could recite the Arya
Sanghatasutra four times, and the Sutra
of Golden Light five times. Read whatever you can
each day, until you complete the recitations.
Also, you can take the Eight Mahayana Precepts [see Rinpoche's
Direct and Unmistaken
Method] twice each month. This is very powerful for
purifying past negative karma, as well as for collecting merit,
so that you can have a good rebirth in your next life, when
death comes, which can happen at any time. So, this would
be extremely good.
Regarding reading the two sutras, this is a very important
way to collect extensive merits. Also, reading these two sutras
becomes a very powerful purification practice. If you read
even just two or three words of the Arya Sanghatasutra,
it purifies the five uninterrupted karmas (killing your father,
killing your mother, killing an arhant, drawing blood from
a Buddha, and causing a schism in the sangha community). Even
hearing just two or three words from this sutra is very powerful
purification, so reading the whole sutra is much greater.
Also, by reading these two sutras you collect so much merit,
for your health, long life, protection, and so on. But most
importantly, you collect extensive merit that purifies negative
karma and defilements, so that you can achieve the path as
quickly as possible, liberate many sentient beings from unimaginable
sufferings, and bring them to enlightenment as quickly as
possible—especially the sentient beings who are connected
to you, so that they can meet the Dharma, be free from samsara,
and achieve enlightenment.
It is also very good if you can do a little lamrim meditation
each day, on the lamrim outlines, especially focusing on impermanence,
death, and bodhicitta. You can follow the outlines of the
two ways to generate bodhicitta. For one week focus mainly
on death and impermanence, and then the next week on bodhicitta.
Do this for some time.
Purifying negative karma is one way to not experience problems.
The other solution is to collect extensive merit, so that
you can have fewer problems and experience more success and
happiness. When things are difficult in your life, this is
the result of past negative karma. Whether you experience
this as suffering or happiness depends on how you look at
the situation. If you look at it as pleasure then it becomes
pleasure and happiness. The suffering is transformed into
happiness. This depends on your thinking differently from
how you normally think.
It is good to think in the way it is explained in the
Guru Puja, in the lamrim section:
Should even the environment and the beings therein
Be filled with the fruits of their karmic debts
And unwished for sufferings pour down like rain
We seek your blessings to take these miserable conditions
as a path
By seeing them as causes to exhaust the results of our negative
karma.
In this way you are looking at the problems as purifying
past negative karma. The first way to think when you encounter
problems is to think that they are finishing your past negative
karma.
As Kadampa Geshe Kara Gomchen says:
Even the present little suffering finishes past negative
karma,
And one will have happiness in the future,
Therefore look at the suffering as happiness.
Always remember this quotation, whenever you have difficulties.
Another way is to look at the problems and suffering in
your life as positive. One way they can become positive is
when you experience sufferings on behalf of other sentient
beings. Do the tonglen practice of taking other sentient
beings’ suffering on yourself, as your own suffering.
Take the suffering into your heart, onto your ego, and think
that it destroys your ego, which becomes non-existent. Think
also that your emotional “I” or ego “I”—the
one that cherishes the ego—also becomes non-existent.
Then meditate on that emptiness. This way tonglen becomes
not only a means to develop bodhicitta but also to develop
emptiness. Do this practice regularly, and then, from time
to time, think, “I am experiencing this suffering, these
difficulties and problems, on behalf of all sentient beings.
May they have all happiness, up to enlightenment.”
When you take on others’ suffering, the idea is that
they experience all happiness up to enlightenment. When you
live your life with this attitude as much as possible, then
whatever negative problem occurs only appears to you as an
incredible opportunity. This also depends on how strongly
you recollect how very kind and precious sentient beings are
to you, and how much they are suffering. Through this, one
feels their unbearable suffering.
In this way, every second that you experience suffering
for others, you collect merit as vast as the sky, and purify
eons of negative karma. Each time, you become closer to enlightenment
and closer to enlightening other sentient beings.
This is the way to develop bodhicitta. By experiencing suffering
for others, one can see that this is the happiest life. There
is no happier life than this in the world.
When you are experiencing difficulties or problems in your
life, normally you label the problem as a problem, and then
you experience suffering, because of the way phenomena appear,
including the “I,” action, and objects. Even though
the way an object (as well as the “I” and action)
exists is to exist in mere name—merely imputed by the
mind—it doesn’t appear to us in that way. Its
appearance is totally opposite to how it is in reality. It
appears to be not merely labeled by the mind. It appears as
real, and existing from its own side. This is a complete hallucination.
This is the object to be refuted. If you look at this as an
hallucination, or as the object to be refuted, you decide
in your heart that the problem is empty or an hallucination.
Because of that, suddenly you don’t see it as a problem
in your life.
Usually, when there is an hallucinated appearance, a truly-existent
appearance, you make your mind believe in the hallucinated
appearance, that it is reality. Then, on that basis, other
exaggerations occur, and you see the appearances as bad, or
you label them bad, and then they become a basis for anger
to arise.
Another thing we do is exaggerate the base and label an
object as beautiful, and from that attraction arises, or some
other delusion. From that hallucinated base, other delusions
arise, such as jealousy and so forth, and this is how one’s
problems come from own one’s mind. Knowing this, you
know immediately what to do – how to switch your way
of thinking to looking at the situation as an hallucination,
as empty. In this way, you can stop problems in your mind
by meditating on emptiness.
You mentioned in your letter how the problems come from
within your mind. First, suffering comes from your mind because
the cause is karma: one’s own mental factors and a negative
intention. This means your mind can stop the suffering by
purifying the cause of the suffering. Your mind can experience
happiness and success, because your mind can create the causes:
the good karma.
For example, if you practice covetousness, it causes you
to experience failure. But if you rejoice in others’
good fortune, and in good things that happen to others, that
becomes the cause of your great success.
Also, if you experience envy or jealousy, not wanting others
to have happiness, realizations, material wealth, or good
friends, thinking this way becomes the cause to experience
failure.
From this, you can see how everything comes from your mind.
All happiness and success comes from your mind. It depends
on what label you put on experience and then your believing
in that label, whether it is “happiness” or “problem.”
Therefore, you can see, as it is mentioned in the lamrim teachings
on thought transformation in the Guru Puja, always
keep your mind in a state of happiness, only putting a positive
label on phenomena.
As I mentioned before, by doing this you will eliminate
your past negative karma and then you will have a better life
and future happiness. Transform your mind with bodhicitta.
This brings happiness based on the thought of experiencing
suffering for others.
If you are able, do what Geshe Jampa Gyatso advised, applying
effort without letting your mind fall into laziness or distraction
due to pleasure. As you saw before, without Dharma practice,
your life will become miserable, and when you practice Dharma,
it brings so much satisfaction and fulfillment.
You are in my prayers. Be happy. It looks like you need
a more fixed schedule for the different practices that you
are doing. This keeps you strong, so you have a stable, happy
mind.
With much love and prayers...
| Taking on Obstacles |
|
| A student went to do a three-year retreat
in the USA, but one and a half years into the retreat
she came out to be with her father while he was dying.
Afterward, she found it hard to go back into retreat,
and for other reasons as well, became depressed. Rinpoche
wrote her this card while he was leading a Mitukpa retreat
in the Milarepa center in Vermont. |
Dear Nancy,
How are you? I heard you are very depressed. Do you know why?
Is it because you had a family member die and had to break
retreat, or because other people seem happier, or is it because
there was no success in the retreat? If it is to do with how
you see others, then it is easy. Just rejoice, then you collect
so much merit, and that brings you to enlightenment, and to
enlighten others, who are countless, and so it brings you
so much happiness and peace in your heart.
If it is because of other distractions, then think, “It
is not a distraction. It is practice.” Think, “I
am taking on the obstacles of other sentient beings, and letting
them have all the opportunities and happiness.”
Do that meditation, and many times a day, think, “I
am experiencing the obstacles to success on behalf of sentient
beings.” Then you achieve realizations quicker, like
Asanga achieved the vision of Maitreya Buddha; Kadampa Geshe
Chekawa had a vision of a pure land at the time of his death,
as a result of praying to be reborn in the hell realms; and
Getsul Tsubuwa went to Vajrayogini’s pure land with
his own body.
One should plan to practice Dharma for eons, and to bear
hardships for Dharma practice for eons.
Thank you very much.
With much love and prayers...
| Dealing with Sadness |
|
| A student wrote to Rinpoche asking for
advice because he often felt depressed, confused, very
lonely, and agitated. He said that he seemed to have a
lot of obstacles preventing his mind from experiencing
joy. |
Dear Joe,
There is some reason why you feel sad. Look at that situation
as positive instead of negative. This is how you transform
it into happiness, through transforming the mind. The mind
projects a negative label on a situation in life, and this
needs to be transformed into a virtuous thought: compassion,
loving kindness, bodhicitta, cherishing others, and experiencing
suffering for others. In this way, experiencing the problem,
including sadness, is used in the path to achieve enlightenment
for sentient beings, which means it becomes the cause of happiness
for all sentient beings. The other thing is wisdom, looking
at it as empty of existing from its own side.
Here are a few examples. Give the sadness to your ego—the
self-cherishing thought, which has prevented you from achieving
enlightenment, liberation from samsara, and the rest of the
path, from beginningless rebirths up until now. It has made
you suffer so much and caused you to feel this sadness for
beginningless rebirths, not only in this life.
Your ego prevents you from being successful. It interferes
with the happiness of future lives and a good rebirth, causing
continuous suffering. So, give the sadness to your ego to
destroy it, like a bomb, blowing up the self-cherishing thought.
When you do this, you are using your sadness to develop bodhicitta.
Take all sentient beings' sadness on yourself. From time to
time, during the rest of the day, think, “I am experiencing
this on behalf of all sentient beings.” This is the
best meditation.
If you die with this thought, you will be reborn in a pure
land or you will receive a higher rebirth, because you have
bodhicitta. It brings great purification. The stronger you
dedicate yourself to others, with the thought to benefit all
sentient beings, the more negative karma you purify and merit
you collect. You become closer to enlightenment and closer
to being able to enlighten all sentient beings.
The other thing is also to accept your sadness. Think that
it is the result of your past karma: having broken samaya
with the guru, caused sadness to others, or engaged in sexual
misconduct. Depression that occurs without a reason and that
happens at certain times, such as when you get up in the morning,
or at night, is the result of sexual misconduct.
Think: “I created the negative karma, so this sadness
I am experiencing is the result of that.” Accept the
karma. This will also help. Kadampa Geshe Karab Gomchung said:
"Even this small suffering now helps to finish past negative
karma and there will be happiness in the future.” It
is good to think like this. Transform the problem into happiness
in relation to karma.
Every day, recite one mala of the name of the Medicine Buddha
Glorious One Free from Sorrow (NYA NGEN ME CHOG PEL). Nectar
beams enter your body and mind, purifying all your harms from
spirits, downfalls, negative karmas, and delusions and their
imprints. You receive all the buddhas' wisdom, compassion,
and power. Then, your whole body is filled with joy. The nectar
fills you with bliss, especially your heart and chakras. (Also,
recite the names of the Seven Medicine Buddhas seven times,
but do one mala of this name with the meditation. Practice
it with a motivation of bodhicitta and a dedication at the
end.)
Thank you very much. I hope this will help you. Goodbye.
With much love and prayer,
Zopa
PS - If there is a reason for your sadness, such as committing
negative karma, it can always be purified. Everything can
be changed. But if the sadness means you are incapable of
doing your work, study, practice, or other things, then one
way to think is that there are many other beings who are much
worse off than you. That way you see your situation is not
so bad and that brings happiness. Don’t think that it
is hopeless. Think, "I will put in more effort. I will
try. I will be better." Encourage yourself. For example,
if you are unable to do your practice, missed your practice,
encourage yourself, "Again, I will try. I must try."
Think of the opportunity you have rather than seeing it as
hopeless. This will help.
Dealing with Depression
Rinpoche received a letter from a student asking how to deal
with her depression.
My very dear Jenny,
Thank you so much for your email.
Use your depression by experiencing it with compassion.
Meditate on taking on all sentient beings’ depression
and suffering and the cause of that suffering. It comes to
you and absorbs into your heart. Your self-cherishing thought
is destroyed. Even the inherently existent “I”
becomes non-existent, the “I” that appears as
if it were truly existent.
Perform this practice with compassion for others who have
more depression than you. Numberless beings experience depression
for many lifetimes, without end. Think, “I am just one
living being. No matter how much suffering I experience, others
who are numberless, have so much more suffering.” Think,
“By my receiving all this depression, they are free
of all suffering and have all happiness up to liberation and
enlightenment. I experience it for them, and let them have
all happiness up to enlightenment. How wonderful to be able
to do this, because all my happiness is due to the kindness
of each sentient being. They are the most precious objects
in my life, from whom I receive all my happiness.”
Then generate loving kindness: “I must cause them
to have happiness and the cause of happiness.” They
receive whatever they want and need, all their pleasure becomes
the pleasure of the pure land of the Buddha where no problems
exist. They receive from you the purest, highest sense pleasures,
enjoyment, beauty: everything they need. That causes them
to actualize the whole path to enlightenment. Their mind becomes
the Dharmakaya, their body becomes the Rupakaya. All become
enlightened.
Perform this meditation, if possible, in the morning, afternoon,
and night, taking and giving 5, 10, 20 times or more. Spend
more time taking. While eating, walking, and at other times
think, “I am experiencing this depression on behalf
of all sentient beings.” Think it is not your depression.
Enjoy your depression by voluntarily taking on the experience
for numberless sentient beings and giving the depression to
your ego, destroying it completely. Enjoy depression in this
way.
Think of the depression as purification of past negative
karma, “If I don't experience this now, I will have
to experience the hell realms for many years, so it is good
to have it now.”
Also think, “I am experiencing past heavy negative
karma. This is being purified by my experiencing this.”
Experience the depression on behalf of all sentient beings.
Use it to purify the cause of depression and all negative
karma. Use the depression to achieve happiness, like transforming
poison into medicine, like, for example, snake venom that
is used for medicine.
Also, use depression to collect extensive merit. This way
your depression becomes like many hundreds of thousands of
prostrations and recitation of powerful deities’ mantras.
It becomes like preliminary practices for purifying and collecting
extensive merit, such as by making mandala offerings.
Work for other sentient beings to collect merit and purify.
Here, you are using your depression to achieve not just temporal
happiness but ultimate happiness. Transform it into the path
to enlightenment. Use it to develop compassion for other sentient
beings and bodhicitta. It is not only the cause to achieve
your own enlightenment but it brings ultimate happiness, up
to enlightenment, for all sentient beings. So, enjoy depression
in this way.
At the beginning it is good to accept your depression, thinking
“I deserve this.” That can help. Start with that.
Use the depression for meditation to develop renunciation
of samsara, bodhicitta, and right view. This way your depression
is used so as to be totally free of depression forever. It
becomes the best Dharma practice and best way of healing.
Usually, taking medicine and following psychological advice
doesn’t do anything for the cause of depression, although
it forces the problem down for a short time. It is like drinking
alcohol. When it is gone from the body, the problem is still
there.
If you have depression due to a particular reason, for example,
a relationship problem, meditate on that situation. If the
depression is without reason, then do the mediation I have
explained here.
Using depression to develop compassion enables us to achieve
enlightenment as quickly as possible. It allows us to free
sentient beings from suffering and bring them to enlightenment
more quickly. So, enjoy all these benefits of depression,
by thinking about them clearly.
More talks by Lama Zopa on this topic:
See the Depression topic
in the Emotions chapter of the Advice Book.
See also the Problems During One's
Practice topic in the Practice Advice chapter.
|